Hafta 269: Coronavirus and India’s lockdown, the role of journalists during a crisis, police brutality, and more

In this episode of NL Hafta, Newslaundry ’s Abhinandan Sekhri, Raman Kirpal, Manisha Pande, and Mehraj D Lone are joined by data journalist Rukmini S.

Abhinandan begins by bringing up Rukmini’s piece in The Print where she wrote that India could see up to 30,000 COVID-19 deaths by May. She says this is not her prediction — it’s based on current growth rate of cases, trajectories of other countries, and predictable modeling done by statisticians that show similar pathways, so this could be the direction India is headed.

“Even with significant intervention, there will be not an ending, but a reduction [in cases],” Rukmini says.

Discussing how the 21-day nationwide lockdown was imposed by Narendra Modi to enforce social distancing, both Raman and Mehraj think India won't be able to handle that many patients. Mehraj asks what measures exist for the homeless, and those dependent on daily wages.

Raman also cites data* on the state of public healthcare in India, such as the fact that India has only 9,512 ICU beds for its 130-crore population.

Bringing up the WHO’s guidelines and its emphasis on community outreach, Manisha says she was stunned by Modi’s decision on the lockdown and the manner in which he communicated it to the public. “Someone who supposedly was a chaiwallah, who rose from nowhere, is so out of touch with how Indians live.” Abhinandan says there’s a sense of “theatre” in what Modi does, in contrast to the Kerala health minister’s low-profile press briefings every day.

The panel also discusses the role of journalists during a crisis like the coronavirus pandemic, India’s support for public institutions, police brutality, and much more.

Tune in!

*The data Raman cited — number of ventilators, ICU beds, isolation beds exclusively earmarked across states to treat COVID-19 patients — is as of March 24. This data is changing dynamically as more capacity is added on a daily basis. For instance, on March 26, the capacity was upgraded to 85,976 isolation beds, 22,772 ICU beds, and 14245 ventilators.

Correction: Raman said Delhi has 252 ICU beds. The number is actually for ventilators.

Song: Aerosmith - Livin’ On The Edge

Hafta letters: Data gap in coronavirus numbers, government incompetence, building a community

References

At current rate, India can see 30,000 COVID-19 deaths by May, no hospital bed by June: Data

PM’s house on Rajpath: How a super elite is capturing Delhi’s land

Gujarat Model 2.0: The super elite’s magic wand to take over public space

Journalism in the time of corona: This is the biggest story of our lives

Why India doesn’t seem to care about its poor even during a pandemic

Recommendations

Rukmini

How the Coronavirus Could Take Over Your Body (Before You Ever Feel It)

Anything written by Anuja Chauhan

Amelia Bedelia series

Manisha

Spanish flu: How information policing and nationalist propaganda worsened a pandemic a century ago

It takes a whole world to create a new virus, not just China

The People in Charge See an Opportunity

WHO Press Briefing - 13th March, 2020

WHO Press Briefing - 23th March, 2020

How wildlife trade is linked to coronavirus

Mehraj

Underlying Conditions: India’s coronavirus crisis was decades in the making

Delhi carnage: The story of one mob, two drains, and five murders

Abhinandan

NPR Planet Money: Pandemic Bonds

#Covid19: Dr WHO gets prescription wrong

Nur Jahan Ke Mazar Par

Taj Mahal

Raman

From best to worst scenario, India will need thousands of ventilators, upgraded health infra to tackle virus: ICMR

Netflix: Freud

Produced and recorded by Aditya Varier, edited by Harshula Sharma.

You can also listen to all our podcasts on the Newslaundry app and get updates about them via Twitter and Facebook .

Hafta 269: India’s lockdown, the role of journalists during a crisis, police brutality, and more

Subscribe now to unlock the story

Why should I pay for news?

You may also like